Award-Winning Restaurants in Marathon, FL

Delicious Dining On-Site at Butterfly Cafe and TJ's Tiki Bar

Discover a bounty of delectable delights mere steps from your accommodations. Embrace the flavors of the tropics and dine at Butterfly Café, featuring a menu of local ingredients and artful preparation.  Poolside? Enjoy a casual Marathon dining atmosphere at TJ’s Tiki Bar, with cold drinks and island treats. Whatever your craving may be, you can experience the best restaurants in Marathon, FL during your stay at Tranquility Bay

Butterfly Café

Our Marathon, Florida restaurant is a seaside favorite for romantic dinners or family meals. Serving seafood, steaks, salads, and more, each option is a tantalizing work of art that is sure to leave a lasting impression on your palette.


TJ’s Tiki Bar

Relax at this beachside hideaway serving an array of appetizing appetizers and craft cocktails that complement our tropical backdrop. Experience TJ’s, a gem among bars in Marathon, FL and find your favorite watering hole.

Florida Keys Dining Hours:

Butterfly Café:
6:00pm – 9:00pm

TJ’s Tiki Bar:
11:00am – 7:00pm