Discover a World of Flavor in the Florida Keys

Feast your eyes on the Florida Keys – a food lover’s paradise where everything tastes better by the sea. Savor world-class cuisine with fresh fish, tropical fruits and local vegetables, all served with a side of year-round sunshine.

Let the flavors of the Keys start your culinary adventure and enjoy the authentic taste of island cuisine at the two restaurants here at Tranquility Bay Resort.

Fresh New Menu at TJ’s Tiki Bar

For daytime dining, take a seat beachside and indulge with an enticing new lunch menu of fresh Florida Keys flavors at TJ’s Tiki Bar.

From appetizers and pizzas to salads, sandwiches, and delicious desserts, menu highlights include our smoked fish dip, blackened shrimp salad, and the irresistible homemade Key lime pie. Prepare to find the perfect lunchtime spot with front row seats to the Gulf of Mexico, then return at sunset to toast the fiery skies with a frozen cocktail in-hand. TJ’s Tiki Bar is open daily from 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m.

Fine Dining at the Elegant Butterfly Cafe

There’s no need to venture far to discover an indulgent dining scene for evening feasting in Marathon. Onsite is our award-winning Butterfly Café with its focus on local ingredients and ocean-fresh seafood. Guests can dine in the spacious dining room with beautiful exposed ceiling or outdoors on the charming covered patio, while sampling the delights of succulent shrimp cocktail, tropical crab cakes, or horseradish-encrusted Florida grouper.

Taking inspiration from the Caribbean, the menu also features a choice of favorites, including jerk chicken and coconut shrimp. The whole family can feast in style, with younger diners catered for with our Little Caterpillars menu.

Experience the Taste of the Florida Keys

Ready to indulge? Dive into our Tranquility Bay Culinary Package, which offers up to 10% off and a $50 dining credit per night to spend in Butterfly Café or TJ’s Tiki Bar (up to a maximum of $250 based on a stay of 5 nights or more).

View our helpful planning guide and special offers, including our Culinary Package and Best Flexible Rate – perfect for if your plans may change – and book your idyllic Florida Keys vacation at Tranquility Bay.

Book online