ReserveNow
Online Reservation

Holiday Dining

CELEBRATE THE SEASON 

The holidays are fast approaching bringing with it the anticipation of family, fun, and food. Whether you're a local or just in town for the holiday, Tranquility Bay has a variety of offerings that are sure to satisfy every guest.

Join us at the award-winning Butterfly Cafe and enjoy specialty seasonal menus for a limited time. 

Learn more about Butterfly Cafe

Thanksgiving, November 24: 2pm to 9pm 

Savor the classic Thanksgiving meal with traditional sides and starters or choose from an exotic island-inspired menu featuring Tranquility Bay favorites. Enjoy Oven Roasted Turkey with Hunter Gravy or Honey Glazed Ham with Pineapple Chutney. Savor side options like Ginger Spiced Cranberry Relish, Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes, Seasonal Vegetables, Stuffing, and Pecan & Marshmallow topped Sweet Potato. Be sure to leave room for our famous TDF 'To Die For' Sticky Toffee Pudding. 

VIEW MENU

MAKE A RESERVATION

A Turkey On A Plate

Christmas Eve, December 24: 4pm to 9pm

Eat, drink, and be merry! Locals and travelers can enjoy an array of mouth-watering options such as creamy Lobster Bisque, Traditional Bahamian Style Chowder, Seared Scallop Risotto, Surf & Turf, and Panko Crusted Grouper with Tropical Coulis. 

VIEW MENU

MAKE A RESERVATION

Christmas Day, December 25: 4pm to 9pm

A Festive Florida Keys twist! We're dishing up some extra special additions to the menu. Enjoy Oven Roasted Breast Turkey with Hunter Gravy, Yellowtail Francaise in a Lemon Caper Butter Sauce, and the "Cowboy" 22 oz Bone-In Angus Ribeye with Truffled Bistro Fries. Finish it off with our signature Key Lime pie to add a bit of that Florida touch.

VIEW MENU

MAKE A RESERVATION

A Turkey On A Table

New Year's Eve, December 31: 5pm to 9pm

Tranquility Bay is making this New Year's Eve extra special! We're offering a four-course tasting menu. Choose your favorites from a specialty tasting menu. The Four-Course Dinner features plenty of options, including Lump Crabcakes with Jicama Slaw, Crab Stuffed Hogfish in a Passion Fruit Sauce, Lamb Chops in a Thyme Balsamic Reduction, and "TDF"-- our warm date cake topped with our "to die for" toffee sauce. 

Tasting menu $105

Tasting menu with wine pairings $130

VIEW MENU

MAKE A RESERVATION

A Bottle Of Champagne And Glasses Of Champagne On A Table

TJ's Tiki Bar

We are offering a limited menu at TJ's Tiki Bar from 11am to 9pm on Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, and Christmas Day.

Enjoy live music and a early toast to 2023 on the beach at TJ's Tiki Bar until 10pm on New Year's Eve.