Waterfront Dining at Tranquility Bay
Drinks on the sand and award-winning dining await at Tranquility Bay. Consistently ranked among the best restaurants in Marathon, Florida, both Butterfly Café and TJ’s Tiki Bar bring an unparalleled dining experience to our beachfront resort.
With standout menus, superb service and the best sunset views in the entire Keys at TJ’s, our on-site restaurants offer something for every taste, no matter how picky the eater. Both of our Marathon restaurants are open to the public, so whether you’re a local or guest, we’ve got a table for you.
Butterfly Café
Al fresco dining and award-winning cuisine in a casual setting.
- Fresh Seafood
- Patio Seating
- Acclaimed Wine List
TJ's Tiki Bar
Open-air bar with live music on the sand
- Lunch & Dinner
- Live Music
- Sunset Views
In-Room Breakfast
Daily breakfast delivered directly to your room or villa
- Served Daily
- Room Delivery
- Grab-and-Go Options
Dining FAQs
Yes, both Butterfly Café and TJ’s Tiki Bar are open to the public and welcome non-resort guests looking to enjoy waterfront restaurants in Marathon Key. Availability may vary during peak hours and high season. Calling ahead or making a reservation is recommended. TJ’s Tiki Bar can be reached at (305) 289-2932, while the number for Butterfly Café is 305-289-7177.
Yes, Tranquility Bay can accommodate large groups and private dining experiences at both Butterfly Café and TJ’s Tiki Bar. Whether you’re planning a celebration, rehearsal dinner, or group gathering, the team can help arrange a memorable waterfront dining experience in the Florida Keys. For more information on private events, please contact our sales team by filling out a request for proposal.
Yes, both Butterfly Café and TJ’s Tiki Bar are available for buyouts and can be reserved for private events. For more information on events and buyouts at our Marathon, FL, resort, please contact our sales team by filling out a request for proposal.
Reservations are recommended for dinner at Butterfly Café, especially during peak travel seasons in the Florida Keys, while walk-ins are welcome at TJ’s Tiki Bar and seating is available on a first-come, first-served basis.
Tranquility Bay offers family-friendly dining options, particularly at TJ’s Tiki Bar, where the relaxed atmosphere and varied menu make it a great choice for guests of all ages. Additionally, Butterfly Café also features a special kids’ menu for even the pickiest of eaters.
Tranquility Bay offers a range of Florida Keys dining experiences, from upscale, award-winning cuisine at Butterfly Café to relaxed, beachside dining and cocktails at TJ’s Tiki Bar. Guests can enjoy fresh seafood, tropical flavors, and ocean views throughout.
Yes! Tranquility Bay offers convenient on-site dining and beverage options, including waterfront dining, cocktails, poolside service, and grab-and-go offerings designed to make your stay effortless and enjoyable. To help maintain a clean, comfortable, and elevated resort experience for all guests, outside food, beverages, and coolers are not allowed at our pools and beachfront areas.
While our dining outlets are only open for lunch and dinner, we do offer guests complimentary pastries, seasonal tropical fruit, and coffee in the morning for purchase inside the lobby. We also have in-room breakfast available for delivery. Scan the dining QR code found inside your accommodations for more information, or stop by the front desk for an order form.