An Upscale, Waterfront Restaurant in Marathon

With fresh-caught fish and island fare, Butterfly Café brings the flavor of the Florida Keys to life. Surrounded by towering palms, our award-winning waterfront restaurant offers a menu that draws inspiration from an array of coastal cuisine for an elevated dining experience that is sure to please.

Dine al fresco on the porch for views of our Lagoon Pool accompanied by the sea breeze, or sit inside amid sophisticated decor, underscored by friendly service and an acclaimed wine list. But whatever you do, make sure to save room for dessert. Our TDF “To Die For” Sticky Toffee Pudding has made a name for itself in the Keys, among guests and locals alike.

Reservations305-289-7177

Butterfly Café Hours

Open Daily

6:00pm – 9:00pm

  • Open concept living and dining area of a 2-Bedroom Beachfront Villa at Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort in the Florida Keys.
Order In

In-Room Dining

Want to dine on your porch instead? The full Butterfly Café menu is available to order directly to your accommodation. Think romantic meals at sunset or low-key dinners after a day exploring the Keys. Simply dial extension 7177 from your room or villa, and we’ll send it over shortly. Menu based on availability.

Call to Order
  • Interior of Butterfly Café at Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort, in Marathon, FL.
Butterfly Café Buyouts

Private Events

Butterfly Café is also available for private events and special occasions. Whether you’re planning a family reunion or a wedding brunch, you’ll find a refined menu, an inviting space, and unmatched views of our Lagoon Pool. Our team will work with you to create an event you’ll remember for years to come.

Event InquiriesLearn More
Butterfly Café

Gift Cards

Share Butterfly Café with your friends and family. Gift cards to our award-winning waterfront restaurant are available in a range of amounts and can be sent digitally — perfect for birthdays, thank-yous, or just because.

Purchase Gift Cards

Butterfly Café FAQ

Is Butterfly Café open to the public?

Yes. Butterfly Café is one of the few Marathon, Florida Keys restaurants open to both resort guests and the public. Reservations are recommended and can be made through OpenTable or by calling 305-289-7177.

What are Butterfly Café's hours?

Butterfly Café is open daily for dinner from 6:00pm to 9:00pm.

Is Butterfly Café open for breakfast or lunch?

Butterfly Café serves dinner only, daily from 6:00pm to 9:00pm. For daytime dining, our beachfront restaurant, TJ’s Tiki Bar, is open for lunch.

Where is Butterfly Café located?

Butterfly Café is located on the grounds of Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort at 2600 Overseas Highway in Marathon, Florida. The waterfront restaurant overlooks the resort’s Lagoon Pool.

Do I need a reservation?

Reservations are recommended. You can reserve a table through OpenTable or by calling 305-289-7177.

Can I order Butterfly Café to my room or villa?

Yes. The Butterfly Café menu is available for in-room dining, based on availability. All orders are delivered directly to your guest room or villa.

Can I book Butterfly Café for a private event?

Yes. Butterfly Café is available for private events and special occasions such as family reunions and wedding brunches. Buyouts are for the full restaurant only, and event dining is served buffet or family-style. For more information, please contact our sales team.

Do you offer gift cards?

Yes. Butterfly Café gift cards are available for purchase here.

  • Risotto at Butterfly Cafe, at Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort in the Florida Keys.
  • Dinner on the patio at Butterfly Cafe, at Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort in the Florida Keys.
  • Interior of Butterfly Café at Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort, in Marathon, FL.
  • Crab-stuffed yellowtail at Butterfly Café, located at Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort, in Marathon, FL.