Online Reservation

A Decadent Selection in Marathon, FL Restaurants

Dine Deliciously in the Keys

Savor Florida Keys dining with award winning cuisine indoors or out at Tranquility Bay's onsite restaurants. Our very own Butterfly Café, rated as the best restaurant in Marathon for five years running, captures the essence of the islands with an emphasis on quality, local ingredients and, of course, ocean fresh seafood. Open daily for dinner, the menu and wine list at Butterfly Café change seasonally. Children will delight in a special menu designed just for them at this delightful Marathon, Florida restaurant.

At Tranquility Bay, options abound for varied Florida Keys restaurant experiences.

Regular Menus

An outdoor dining area surrounded by tropical foliage.

Enjoy our waterfront Tiki Bar and select from a menu that includes bountiful salads, mouthwatering paninis and more. Also enjoy watching your favorite sporting events at the beachside, T.J.’s Tiki Bar. Our appetizers are scrumptious and draft beer refreshing, while tropical drinks will dance on the palate in the company of the Florida Keys' high-definition sunsets.

Tranquility Bay specializes in preparing the freshest fish offered at Florida Keys restaurants. 

Click Here to View the TJ's Tiki Bar Lunch and Drink Menu

TJ's Tiki Bar at sunset.